[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"transcript-8805b4b8-3ce7-4585-8889-200a2172e16c-en":3,"footer-top-topics-en":501,"footer-top-speakers-en":552,"transcript-poster-8805b4b8-3ce7-4585-8889-200a2172e16c":658},{"falas":4,"lang":490,"meta":491},[5,14,28,35,43,51,57,69,75,81,86,92,104,110,118,123,133,141,146,151,158,162,167,172,180,184,188,198,206,212,220,225,230,234,240,244,248,258,263,267,273,281,285,289,300,305,310,314,319,324,333,343,348,353,358,369,375,380,390,395,400,408,413,418,422,428,433,444,449,456,462,473,479,485],{"idx":6,"utterance_id":7,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":10,"start_s":6,"end_s":11,"word_count":12,"indexable":13},0,"50590","Marcos Rogério","marcos-rogerio","Tomorrow, at 11:00 a.m., at the Public Security Committee; therefore, he will participate.",8.546075085324231,14,false,{"idx":15,"utterance_id":16,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":17,"start_s":11,"end_s":18,"word_count":19,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":22,"target_proposition":23,"stance":24,"stance_confidence":25,"rationale":26,"indexable":27},1,"50591","Now, the extradition request against Tagliaferro is based on a complaint from the Office of the Attorney General, which alleges crimes such as breach of official confidentiality, obstruction of proceedings and of the investigation, and coercion in the course of the proceedings.",31.742564602632864,38,"processo-penal","Criminal Procedure","e3f4d044-9c77-4f38-989e-edaeb67dca0f","conduct extradition proceedings according to legal criteria","neutro_descritivo",0.85,"reports the legal grounds that support the extradition request.",true,{"idx":29,"utterance_id":30,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":31,"start_s":18,"end_s":32,"word_count":33,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":22,"target_proposition":23,"stance":24,"stance_confidence":25,"rationale":34,"indexable":27},2,"50592","Italy, as we all know, with which Brazil has maintained an extradition treaty since 1989, will have to assess whether the case meets the legal criteria.",47.613846903949295,26,"explains that Italy will assess the case according to the extradition treaty.",{"idx":36,"utterance_id":37,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":38,"start_s":32,"end_s":39,"word_count":40,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":22,"target_proposition":23,"stance":24,"stance_confidence":41,"rationale":42,"indexable":27},3,"50593","And when we talk here about fitting the legal criteria, it is because, under the law that deals with these conditions for the extradition process between Brazil and Italy... among the criteria is the motive.",68.97903461725987,35,0.82,"says there are legal criteria to be applied in the process.",{"idx":44,"utterance_id":45,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":46,"start_s":39,"end_s":47,"word_count":48,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":22,"target_proposition":23,"stance":24,"stance_confidence":49,"rationale":50,"indexable":27},4,"50594","If the motive is political—some form of political persecution of a legal nature—extradition is prohibited under that provision between the two countries.",84.23988298391028,25,0.86,"states a legal rule that bars extradition for political motivation.",{"idx":52,"utterance_id":53,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":54,"start_s":47,"end_s":55,"word_count":56,"indexable":13},5,"50595","But there is a central point that needs to be debated.",89.73378839590444,9,{"idx":58,"utterance_id":59,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":60,"start_s":55,"end_s":61,"word_count":33,"topic_slug":62,"topic_label":63,"target_id":64,"target_proposition":65,"stance":66,"stance_confidence":67,"rationale":68,"indexable":13},6,"50596","Are we facing an ordinary criminal or someone who made public information of collective interest, information of interest to Brazilian society?",105.60507069722087,"protecao-a-denunciantes","Whistleblower Protection","4c0654cd-28e7-4481-b3c9-4c805b8b4aee","implement whistleblower protection and reward programs","ambiguo",0.55,"asks whether he is an ordinary criminal or a whistleblower of public interest, without concluding.",{"idx":70,"utterance_id":71,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":72,"start_s":61,"end_s":73,"word_count":74,"indexable":13},7,"50597","Are we facing an ethical conflict? Are we facing a situation in which one must verify what is the object of the investigation, the leaked content, and what it represents in the legal realm?",125.74939054119942,33,{"idx":76,"utterance_id":77,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":78,"start_s":73,"end_s":79,"word_count":80,"indexable":13},8,"50598","And what is the ethical conflict here? What weighs more?",132.4641638225256,11,{"idx":56,"utterance_id":82,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":83,"start_s":79,"end_s":84,"word_count":85,"indexable":13},"50599","What weighs more: institutional secrecy or society's right to know the behind-the-scenes of decisions that affect democracy and therefore affect the lives of millions and millions of Brazilians?",153.21891760117018,34,{"idx":87,"utterance_id":88,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":89,"start_s":84,"end_s":90,"word_count":91,"indexable":13},10,"50600","What weighs more? Because, if you are faced with two situations, this judgment, this weighing must be made.",164.81716235982447,19,{"idx":80,"utterance_id":93,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":94,"start_s":90,"end_s":95,"word_count":96,"topic_slug":97,"topic_label":98,"target_id":99,"target_proposition":100,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":103,"indexable":27},"50601","The revelations known as \"vaza toga\" exposed internal practices of the Judiciary that should never have been handled outside the law.",177.02584105314483,20,"transparencia-e-investigacao","Transparency & Investigation","a995e3f1-0b31-4513-8e34-da1163d09c5a","reduce state secrecy periods and expand transparency of official documents","a_favor",0.9,"says the revelations exposed internal practices that should not remain outside the law.",{"idx":105,"utterance_id":106,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":107,"start_s":95,"end_s":108,"word_count":109,"indexable":13},12,"50602","This is a fact that has been denounced not only, from time to time, here from the rostrum of the Senate by a parliamentarian, but also by the national media, the Brazilian news outlets, the Brazilian press.",195.94929302779133,31,{"idx":111,"utterance_id":112,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":113,"start_s":108,"end_s":114,"word_count":115,"topic_slug":62,"topic_label":63,"target_id":64,"target_proposition":65,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":116,"rationale":117,"indexable":27},13,"50603","And here, instead of looking at the facts and verifying the truthfulness and seriousness of what is being denounced, no—one seeks a messenger to frame, threaten and punish.",215.48317893710384,32,0.88,"criticizes persecuting the messenger instead of investigating the reported facts.",{"idx":12,"utterance_id":119,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":120,"start_s":114,"end_s":121,"word_count":122,"indexable":13},"50604","And then I ask: where is the legal basis for this within the democratic rule of law, within due process?",230.13359336908823,24,{"idx":124,"utterance_id":125,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":126,"start_s":121,"end_s":127,"word_count":85,"topic_slug":128,"topic_label":129,"target_id":130,"target_proposition":131,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":116,"rationale":132,"indexable":27},15,"50605","And at this point a great controversy arises. Minister Alexandre de Moraes, in this case, besides being a direct victim of the revelations, is also the direct person responsible for the extradition request and for conducting the process.",250.88834714773282,"conflito-de-interesses","Conflict of Interest","4c679ef9-1c99-4170-a9d6-4b434ede0e6c","prevent judges from acting as interested parties in cases they hear","says the minister is both a victim and leading the process, pointing to a conflict.",{"idx":134,"utterance_id":135,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":136,"start_s":127,"end_s":137,"word_count":138,"topic_slug":62,"topic_label":63,"target_id":64,"target_proposition":65,"stance":66,"stance_confidence":139,"rationale":140,"indexable":13},16,"50606","And then, the first question: is this a criminal leak or is it a denunciation of relevant facts that society deserves to know, because it offends due process, because there are avenues there that are not lawful?",275.9161384690395,41,0.6,"casts doubt on the nature of the leak without advocating any specific action.",{"idx":142,"utterance_id":143,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":144,"start_s":137,"end_s":145,"word_count":33,"indexable":13},17,"50607","And another point: the one who is denouncing and who, at the same time as denouncing, is also conducting proceedings and now ordering the extradition is a victim.",291.78742077035594,{"idx":147,"utterance_id":148,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":149,"start_s":145,"end_s":150,"word_count":124,"indexable":13},18,"50608","But in what situation of institutional, democratic, legal normality would this be possible, would this be accepted?",300.9439297903462,{"idx":91,"utterance_id":152,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":153,"start_s":150,"end_s":154,"word_count":155,"topic_slug":128,"topic_label":129,"target_id":130,"target_proposition":131,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":156,"rationale":157,"indexable":27},"50609","See, I repeat: the Minister who requests the extradition is a victim of the revelations, but he is also responsible for conducting the process, conducting the inquiry, ordering measures, measures that could reach the point of imprisoning the whistleblower.",326.58215504631886,42,0.87,"Warns that the minister responsible for the case can arrest the whistleblower.",{"idx":96,"utterance_id":159,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":160,"start_s":154,"end_s":161,"word_count":105,"indexable":13},"50610","And, no less serious than that, is the extradition request.",333.90736226231104,{"idx":163,"utterance_id":164,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":165,"start_s":161,"end_s":166,"word_count":111,"indexable":13},21,"50611","Come on, let's be frank: what is the backdrop to the extradition at this moment?",341.84300341296927,{"idx":168,"utterance_id":169,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":170,"start_s":166,"end_s":171,"word_count":155,"indexable":13},22,"50612","Is it an extradition merely to bring him back to Brazil: \"Look, this former staffer must return to Brazil, because Brazil is a wonderful country, it has wonderful beaches, wonderful cities, and it is better to be in Brazil than in Italy\"?",367.481228668942,{"idx":173,"utterance_id":174,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":175,"start_s":171,"end_s":176,"word_count":91,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":177,"target_proposition":178,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":49,"rationale":179,"indexable":27},23,"50613","Is that it? No. They want to bring him to Brazil because they want to put him behind bars, because they want to order preventive detention.",379.0794734275963,"24fe5ffc-69ae-4b11-b9be-cef93ce9ac82","ensure respect for due process in extradition proceedings","Questions whether extradition aims to arrest and coerce the whistleblower.",{"idx":122,"utterance_id":181,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":182,"start_s":176,"end_s":183,"word_count":56,"indexable":13},"50614","And what is that? Is it coercion? Is it a threat?",384.5733788395905,{"idx":48,"utterance_id":185,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":186,"start_s":183,"end_s":187,"word_count":12,"indexable":13},"50615","Is it a culture of fear? Is it the imposition of fear as a mechanism of control?",393.1194539249147,{"idx":33,"utterance_id":189,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":190,"start_s":187,"end_s":191,"word_count":142,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":194,"target_proposition":195,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":196,"rationale":197,"indexable":27},"50616","See, Mr. President, I am bringing this fact for debate in the Plenary because it is becoming the rule.",403.49683081423694,"poder-judiciario","Judiciary","61137303-9ef5-41bc-a2d4-5ea22ff96b5d","ensure trial in the competent forum and respect for due process",0.8,"Raises the case for debate because it is becoming a recurring practice.",{"idx":199,"utterance_id":200,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":201,"start_s":191,"end_s":202,"word_count":155,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":203,"target_proposition":204,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":25,"rationale":205,"indexable":27},27,"50617","This happened in relation to those accused of involvement in January 8, in the occupation, depredation and vandalism that occurred in the public spaces of the Parliament, the Judiciary and the Planalto (Presidential Palace), and then you again have someone who denounces being treated as a criminal.",429.13505607020966,"cec83dee-dc1c-44e0-9e37-0ad64f2605fe","ensure the Judiciary's independence and impartiality","Compares cases and criticizes treating the whistleblower as a criminal.",{"idx":207,"utterance_id":208,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":209,"start_s":202,"end_s":210,"word_count":142,"topic_slug":128,"topic_label":129,"target_id":130,"target_proposition":131,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":211,"indexable":27},28,"50618","In any republican system, it is inadmissible that someone be simultaneously an interested party and judge of their own case.",439.5124329595319,"States it is unacceptable for a judge to be both an interested party and the judge of their own case.",{"idx":213,"utterance_id":214,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":215,"start_s":210,"end_s":216,"word_count":122,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":217,"target_proposition":218,"stance":24,"stance_confidence":196,"rationale":219,"indexable":27},29,"50619","Moreover, the Brazilian Code of Civil Procedure – and the Code of Criminal Procedure, likewise – make this impediment clear.",454.1628473915163,"a531bc71-9256-4e41-93f5-0b70f350af5e","apply recusal and disqualification of judges with conflicts of interest","Cites the Code of Procedure that provides for legal disqualification of interested parties.",{"idx":221,"utterance_id":222,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":223,"start_s":216,"end_s":224,"word_count":124,"indexable":13},30,"50620","A judge who has an interest in the case, or their spouse, cannot participate in the proceedings.",463.3193564115066,{"idx":109,"utterance_id":226,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":227,"start_s":224,"end_s":228,"word_count":199,"topic_slug":20,"topic_label":21,"target_id":177,"target_proposition":178,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":41,"rationale":229,"indexable":27},"50621","This is a basic principle of law. Now, at the same time, it is important to ask: would the use of extradition in this case be a type of persecution of the whistleblower?",479.801072647489,"Questions whether the use of extradition amounts to persecution of the whistleblower.",{"idx":115,"utterance_id":231,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":232,"start_s":228,"end_s":233,"word_count":115,"indexable":13},"50622","Wouldn't that drive away whistleblowers? And here I am issuing a warning, because what is being done now to this former court staffer, this former aide, is also a message to any whistleblower.",499.3349585568016,{"idx":74,"utterance_id":235,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":236,"start_s":233,"end_s":237,"word_count":238,"topic_slug":62,"topic_label":63,"target_id":64,"target_proposition":65,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":116,"rationale":239,"indexable":27},"50623","And then you have the State, through one of its branches, the Judiciary, saying clearly: \"Look, depending on who denounces, the State, which should protect the whistleblower in order to investigate the content brought to the public, will invert: instead of looking at the facts, it will look at the whistleblower, to disqualify him or to lock him up behind bars!\"",537.7922964407605,63,"Says the State has been inverting protection, targeting the whistleblower instead of the facts.",{"idx":85,"utterance_id":241,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":242,"start_s":237,"end_s":243,"word_count":207,"indexable":13},"50624","And I ask: would this not drive away whistleblowers, journalists or citizens who are willing to reveal irregularities in public administration and, above all — I warn here — in the Judiciary?",554.8844466114091,{"idx":40,"utterance_id":245,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":246,"start_s":243,"end_s":247,"word_count":111,"indexable":13},"50625","We are faced with a question that must be placed on the debate.",562.8200877620673,{"idx":249,"utterance_id":250,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":251,"start_s":247,"end_s":252,"word_count":122,"topic_slug":253,"topic_label":254,"target_id":255,"target_proposition":256,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":49,"rationale":257,"indexable":27},36,"50626","But, beyond this aspect, I would like to add that this Tagliaferro situation reveals an incoherence in our accusatory justice system.",577.4705021940517,"sistema-de-justica-juvenil","Juvenile justice system","5dacb601-f507-4530-b17a-a310d16947f3","preserve the Public Ministry's role as the holder of criminal prosecution","Alleges usurpation of the accusatory role by the Judiciary, marginalizing the Public Prosecutor's Office (MP).",{"idx":259,"utterance_id":260,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":261,"start_s":252,"end_s":262,"word_count":207,"indexable":13},37,"50627","Notice that I am bringing here, I am coining a phrase that is not everyday: \"accusatory justice,\" because that is not the role of the Judiciary.",594.5626523647002,{"idx":19,"utterance_id":264,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":265,"start_s":262,"end_s":266,"word_count":142,"indexable":13},"50628","We understand and know, in the light of the law, in the light of the Constitution, that the role of accusation...",604.9400292540224,{"idx":268,"utterance_id":269,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":270,"start_s":266,"end_s":271,"word_count":19,"topic_slug":253,"topic_label":254,"target_id":255,"target_proposition":256,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":25,"rationale":272,"indexable":27},39,"50629","Within criminal prosecution, the holder of the public criminal action is the Public Prosecutor's Office, which finds itself, day by day, diminished, with its role relativized, belittled, due to the usurpation of that role by another Power without legitimacy.",628.1365187713311,"Says the holder of the criminal action is the Public Prosecutor's Office (MP) and that this role has been relativized.",{"idx":274,"utterance_id":275,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":276,"start_s":271,"end_s":277,"word_count":278,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":194,"target_proposition":195,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":279,"rationale":280,"indexable":27},40,"50630","That which was an exception within the Court due to a regimental mandate for crimes committed inside the Court – therefore it is no longer an exception – becomes a practice that extends beyond the court's four walls, ordering measures in every corner of Brazil.",656.2164797659678,46,0.84,"Criticizes a practice that exceeds procedural exceptions and affects the whole country.",{"idx":138,"utterance_id":282,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":283,"start_s":277,"end_s":284,"word_count":115,"indexable":13},"50631","And then no longer cares about what the Federal Constitution says, about what the Code of Criminal Procedure says, or about what our special laws say.",675.7503656752804,{"idx":155,"utterance_id":286,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":287,"start_s":284,"end_s":288,"word_count":122,"indexable":13},"50632","Everything relativized — everything relativized! But I insist: this Tagliaferro situation reveals a great incoherence in our accusatory justice system.",690.4007801072647,{"idx":290,"utterance_id":291,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":292,"start_s":288,"end_s":293,"word_count":294,"topic_slug":295,"topic_label":296,"target_id":297,"target_proposition":298,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":116,"rationale":299,"indexable":27},43,"50633","While an extradition is requested for a man accused of passing on information of public interest, we witness leaks of private conversations between Pastor Silas Malafaia and the Bolsonaro family, personal dialogues with no public or institutional character, that were exposed without judicial authorization, in flagrant violation of privacy and legality.",722.1433447098976,52,"transparencia-e-sigilo-institucional","Transparency & Institutional Secrecy","8401d9a0-f230-4923-8e86-10538419591e","ensure respect for privacy and legality in disclosing private conversations","Opposes leaks of private dialogues without judicial authorization.",{"idx":301,"utterance_id":302,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":303,"start_s":293,"end_s":304,"word_count":48,"indexable":13},44,"50634","So why, in one case, is the law used to persecute or repress and, in another, does the silence of the institutions cover up the abuses?",737.404193076548,{"idx":306,"utterance_id":307,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":308,"start_s":304,"end_s":309,"word_count":87,"indexable":13},45,"50635","Isn't that a legitimate question? Isn't that a coherent question?",743.5085324232082,{"idx":278,"utterance_id":311,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":312,"start_s":309,"end_s":313,"word_count":96,"indexable":13},"50636","Why, in one case, are the rigors of the law and enforcement applied, and in another, not—everything is fine, everything is normal?",755.7172111165286,{"idx":315,"utterance_id":316,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":317,"start_s":313,"end_s":318,"word_count":105,"indexable":13},47,"50637","\"The ends justify the means, it's all right, we have to expose.",763.0424183325207,{"idx":320,"utterance_id":321,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":322,"start_s":318,"end_s":323,"word_count":163,"indexable":13},48,"50638","He said something there that your audience, your base won't like, so let's release it, it's all right.",775.861530960507,{"idx":325,"utterance_id":326,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":327,"start_s":323,"end_s":328,"word_count":301,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":329,"target_proposition":330,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":331,"rationale":332,"indexable":27},49,"50639","The goal here is to demoralize.\" See, one cannot allow, one cannot accept as normal that a magistrate, especially one who is a member of the highest Court of Justice of the country, uses an extraordinary expedient to invalidate the constitutional norm.",802.7206240858118,"2ea341a0-d915-4b63-a74d-765a99b27efc","make the judiciary comply with the Constitution and the law",0.89,"States that a magistrate cannot use exceptional measures to invalidate a constitutional norm.",{"idx":334,"utterance_id":335,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":336,"start_s":328,"end_s":337,"word_count":85,"topic_slug":338,"topic_label":339,"target_id":340,"target_proposition":341,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":342,"indexable":27},50,"50640","More than the fate of a former aide, this case puts fundamental principles into question: freedom of the press, protection of privacy, transparency of public acts and the limits of judicial action.",823.4753778644563,"liberdade-de-expressao-censura","Freedom of Expression \u002F Censorship","2b0a417e-14f0-48df-80cc-8c79e52ba69c","protect freedom of the press","Puts freedom of the press forward as a principle at stake in the case.",{"idx":344,"utterance_id":345,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":346,"start_s":337,"end_s":347,"word_count":105,"indexable":13},51,"50641","These are principles, these are issues that need to be verified, that need to be analyzed.",830.8005850804486,{"idx":294,"utterance_id":349,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":350,"start_s":347,"end_s":351,"word_count":290,"topic_slug":97,"topic_label":98,"target_id":99,"target_proposition":100,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":352,"indexable":27},"50642","If, on the one hand, it is the State's duty to protect classified information; on the other, it is equally essential to safeguard society's right to know the truth about its rulers and its institutions, without selectivity, without protection, without double standards.",857.0492442710872,"Defends a balance between confidentiality and society's right to know the truth.",{"idx":354,"utterance_id":355,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":356,"start_s":351,"end_s":357,"word_count":249,"indexable":13},53,"50643","What is at stake, Mr. President, therefore, is not only the extradition of a Brazilian citizen, but rather the credibility of the justice system, trust in democracy, and the balance between power and liberty.",879.0248659190638,{"idx":359,"utterance_id":360,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":361,"start_s":357,"end_s":362,"word_count":249,"topic_slug":363,"topic_label":364,"target_id":365,"target_proposition":366,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":367,"rationale":368,"indexable":27},54,"50644","And that is a relevant fact! Therefore it falls to us, as a society and as Parliament, to demand that this process be conducted with full respect for due process of law, without persecution and without abuses of authority.",901.0004875670404,"devido-processo-legal-e-garantias-constitucionais","Due Process and Constitutional Guarantees","4b92eaf7-0bcd-4507-9e98-0131b8a80a97","respect the presumption of innocence and exercise caution in investigations",0.95,"Demands that the process be conducted with full respect for due process of law.",{"idx":370,"utterance_id":371,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":372,"start_s":362,"end_s":373,"word_count":163,"topic_slug":62,"topic_label":63,"target_id":64,"target_proposition":65,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":374,"indexable":27},55,"50645","Brazil needs to set an example that it does not fear the truth and does not confuse a legitimate accusation with a political crime.",913.8196001950269,"Says Brazil must distinguish legitimate reports from political crimes and protect whistleblowers.",{"idx":376,"utterance_id":377,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":378,"start_s":373,"end_s":379,"word_count":111,"indexable":13},56,"50646","The future of our freedoms depends on that distinction, depends on that caution, on that care.",921.755241345685,{"idx":381,"utterance_id":382,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":383,"start_s":379,"end_s":384,"word_count":278,"topic_slug":385,"topic_label":386,"target_id":387,"target_proposition":388,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":196,"rationale":389,"indexable":27},57,"50647","I repeat, this civil servant Eduardo Tagliaferro... I repeat, posing the question, which is what we can do here — we cannot do much more than that, but we still have the possibility to speak out, to say what we think under harsh penalties, and that is a Parliamentary prerogative.",949.8352023403218,"prerrogativas-parlamentares","Parliamentary Prerogatives","9f240113-56cb-4d56-bf11-50fd132315e7","preserve parliamentary immunity provided for in Article 53 of the Constitution","Invokes the parliamentary prerogative to speak and state a position in the plenary.",{"idx":391,"utterance_id":392,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":393,"start_s":384,"end_s":394,"word_count":76,"indexable":13},58,"50648","This young man, this civil servant, is he a defendant? Is he accused?",954.71867381765,{"idx":396,"utterance_id":397,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":398,"start_s":394,"end_s":399,"word_count":76,"indexable":13},59,"50649","Or a cooperating whistleblower? What is his status?",959.602145294978,{"idx":401,"utterance_id":402,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":403,"start_s":399,"end_s":404,"word_count":115,"topic_slug":97,"topic_label":98,"target_id":405,"target_proposition":406,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":156,"rationale":407,"indexable":27},60,"50650","What is the position of this civil servant? When it is convenient, leaking is permitted; when it affects opponents, leaking is normal and tolerated; but when it exposes the system itself, then leaking is a crime.",979.1360312042905,"34d4dcb8-6c3d-4d94-a988-5b52ec03e488","ensure non-selective handling of leaks and uniform application of the law","Criticizes selective legal handling of leaks based on political interests.",{"idx":409,"utterance_id":410,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":411,"start_s":404,"end_s":412,"word_count":56,"indexable":13},61,"50651","We are facing a situation that is absurd.",984.6299366162847,{"idx":414,"utterance_id":415,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":416,"start_s":412,"end_s":417,"word_count":111,"indexable":13},62,"50652","This is not justice, this is selectivity, this is a breakdown of the accusatorial system.",992.5655777669429,{"idx":238,"utterance_id":419,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":420,"start_s":417,"end_s":421,"word_count":142,"indexable":13},"50653","It is the practice of double standards, and this inconsistency destroys confidence in the Judiciary.",1002.9429546562652,{"idx":423,"utterance_id":424,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":425,"start_s":421,"end_s":426,"word_count":40,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":217,"target_proposition":218,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":427,"indexable":27},64,"50654","I conclude with a warning, Mr. President, saying that when Justice becomes a party, it loses the capacity to judge; and when silence is imposed by force, democracy becomes a mere formality.",1024.3081423695758,"Warns that the judiciary loses its ability to judge when it becomes a party.",{"idx":429,"utterance_id":430,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":431,"start_s":426,"end_s":432,"word_count":33,"indexable":13},65,"50655","I repeat, it is up to all of us, as a society and as legitimate representatives of our world and our people, to ensure that this does not happen in Brazil.",1040.1794246708923,{"idx":434,"utterance_id":435,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":436,"start_s":432,"end_s":437,"word_count":199,"topic_slug":438,"topic_label":439,"target_id":440,"target_proposition":441,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":442,"rationale":443,"indexable":27},66,"50656","Last week I spoke, I used a phrase here and I repeat it: it is not the practice of democracies to use a culture of fear as a mechanism of control.",1056.6611409068746,"direitos-politicos","Political Rights","38a09847-acc8-4a51-8b8b-0e1655971d05","combat the use of a culture of fear as a mechanism of political control",0.92,"States that a culture of fear is an instrument of dictatorships, not democracies.",{"idx":445,"utterance_id":446,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":447,"start_s":437,"end_s":448,"word_count":111,"indexable":13},67,"50657","Fear as a mechanism of control is an instrument of dictatorships, not of democracies.",1064.596782057533,{"idx":450,"utterance_id":451,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":452,"start_s":448,"end_s":453,"word_count":454,"topic_slug":438,"topic_label":439,"target_id":440,"target_proposition":441,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":455,"indexable":27},68,"50658","And what seems to me very clear, very evident in Brazil lately, is the relentless pursuit of implanting a culture of fear in Brazil, at times through the conduct of proceedings by improper means, exceeding the limits of due process of law, at other times through the application of disproportionate, excessive penalties, the imputation of non-existent crimes and with the endorsement of the Highest Court, which is even more serious because here you do not have the possibility of review in any other instance.",1113.4314968308142,80,"Denounces the application of disproportionate punishments and improper handling of proceedings.",{"idx":457,"utterance_id":458,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":459,"start_s":453,"end_s":460,"word_count":414,"topic_slug":192,"topic_label":193,"target_id":194,"target_proposition":195,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":49,"rationale":461,"indexable":27},69,"50659","So I make these warnings. This week we will have the start of an emblematic trial — I will return to this subject on the floor of the Senate, bringing here some warnings — and what is happening today in Brazil is something that, in the course of history, will exact a very heavy, very high price from Brazil and from Brazilians.",1151.2784007801074,"Warns that the current conduct of justice will exact a heavy historical price from the country.",{"idx":463,"utterance_id":464,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":465,"start_s":460,"end_s":466,"word_count":467,"topic_slug":468,"topic_label":469,"target_id":470,"target_proposition":471,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":102,"rationale":472,"indexable":27},70,"50660","Therefore, all care, all caution, all prudence in a grave moment such as the one we are passing through demands of everyone — of those who wield the judge's pen and of those who are in the trenches of politics — an understanding of the complexity of everything and, above all, that above all of us is Brazil, are the Brazilians, and over all of us, binding us, is the little green‑covered book, our Federal Constitution.",1197.6713798147246,76,"nova-constituicao-emenda-constitucional","New Constitution \u002F Constitutional amendment","27ac7ea5-e1ae-45e5-a254-da1f2150a99a","ensure observance of the Federal Constitution as the guiding principle of public decisions","Appeals to the Constitution as a guiding beacon and hope in the face of abuses.",{"idx":474,"utterance_id":475,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":476,"start_s":466,"end_s":477,"word_count":325,"topic_slug":468,"topic_label":469,"target_id":470,"target_proposition":471,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":116,"rationale":478,"indexable":27},71,"50661","As long as we have the Constitution as a guide, as a north, we still have or will still have hope; but when we identify, see, observe that this Constitution is used when it suits and discarded when it does not, then we are facing a situation of gravity without precedent in the history of Brazil.",1227.5826426133592,"Warns against using the Constitution selectively for convenience.",{"idx":480,"utterance_id":481,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":482,"start_s":477,"end_s":483,"word_count":109,"topic_slug":363,"topic_label":364,"target_id":365,"target_proposition":366,"stance":101,"stance_confidence":442,"rationale":484,"indexable":27},72,"50662","Either we obey our Constitution and observe due process of law as an instrument of the democratic rule of law, or we are lost and Brazil will go from bad to worse.",1246.506094588006,"Contrasts upholding the Constitution and due process with the country's decline.",{"idx":486,"utterance_id":487,"speaker_name":8,"speaker_slug":9,"text":488,"start_s":483,"end_s":489,"word_count":56,"indexable":13},73,"50663","God bless our Brazil! Thank you very much, Mr. President.",1252,"en",{"job_id":492,"title":493,"source_url":494,"platform":495,"content_type":496,"published_at":497,"n_classified":498,"speakers":499},"8805b4b8-3ce7-4585-8889-200a2172e16c","Pronunciamento","https:\u002F\u002Fwww12.senado.leg.br\u002Fportalcedoc\u002Fpcedoc\u002F2025\u002F20250901\u002F20250901155302_1967521.MP4","senado","senado_speech","2025-09-01T18:23:20Z",74,[500],{"name":8,"slug":9,"n_falas":498},{"limit":87,"offset":6,"topics":502,"total":551},[503,508,513,518,523,528,531,536,541,546],{"label":504,"n_speakers":33,"n_utterances":505,"n_videos":506,"slug":507},"National Security",2695,190,"seguranca-nacional",{"label":509,"n_speakers":115,"n_utterances":510,"n_videos":511,"slug":512},"Education",1685,229,"educacao",{"label":514,"n_speakers":173,"n_utterances":515,"n_videos":516,"slug":517},"Public Safety and Order",1580,244,"seguranca-publica-e-ordem",{"label":519,"n_speakers":74,"n_utterances":520,"n_videos":521,"slug":522},"Combating Impunity",1469,292,"combate-a-impunidade",{"label":524,"n_speakers":115,"n_utterances":525,"n_videos":526,"slug":527},"Monetary Policy",1448,303,"politica-monetaria",{"label":193,"n_speakers":173,"n_utterances":529,"n_videos":530,"slug":192},846,149,{"label":532,"n_speakers":207,"n_utterances":533,"n_videos":534,"slug":535},"Public Service",788,178,"servico-publico",{"label":537,"n_speakers":48,"n_utterances":538,"n_videos":539,"slug":540},"Public Health \u002F Public Safety",756,139,"saude-publica-seguranca-publica",{"label":542,"n_speakers":207,"n_utterances":543,"n_videos":544,"slug":545},"Social Policy",684,197,"politica-social",{"label":547,"n_speakers":168,"n_utterances":548,"n_videos":549,"slug":550},"Fiscal Reform",671,134,"reforma-fiscal",625,{"limit":87,"offset":6,"speakers":553,"total":259},[554,568,581,592,600,611,622,631,638,647],{"slug":555,"name":556,"party":557,"role":557,"state":557,"n_speeches":558,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":559,"photo_url":563,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":564,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":566},"renan-santos","Renan Santos","",22525,[560,561,562],"Abuse of Authority","Administrative and Labor Reform","Affirmative action","\u002Fprofiles\u002Frenan-santos\u002Fphoto.png","Q51882553","none",{"twitter":567},"@RenanSantosMBL",{"slug":569,"name":570,"party":557,"role":557,"state":571,"n_speeches":572,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":573,"photo_url":577,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":578,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":579},"romeu-zema","Romeu Zema","MG",12888,[574,575,576],"Agriculture & Agribusiness","Amnesty and Jan 8 Characterization","Anti-Discrimination","\u002Fprofiles\u002Fromeu-zema\u002Fphoto.png","Q57092113",{"twitter":580},"@RomeuZema",{"slug":582,"name":583,"party":557,"role":557,"state":557,"n_speeches":584,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":585,"bio_short":557,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":589},"pablo-marcal","Pablo Marçal",12772,[586,587,588],"Agricultural Policy","Business Environment","Campaign Financing",{"twitter":590,"youtube":591},"@pablomarcal","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002F@pablomarcall",{"slug":593,"name":594,"party":557,"role":557,"state":595,"n_speeches":596,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":597,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":598,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":599},"fernando-haddad","Fernando Haddad","SP",12647,[586,574,576],"Q3069485",{},{"slug":601,"name":602,"party":557,"role":557,"state":603,"n_speeches":604,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":605,"photo_url":607,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":608,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":609},"ronaldo-caiado","Ronaldo Caiado","GO",12538,[561,562,606],"Agribusiness & Regional Development","\u002Fprofiles\u002Fronaldo-caiado\u002Fphoto.png","Q10364348",{"twitter":610},"@ronaldocaiado",{"slug":612,"name":613,"party":557,"role":614,"state":595,"n_speeches":615,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":616,"photo_url":618,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":619,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":620},"tarcisio","Tarcisio","Governador",11298,[617,586,574],"Age of Criminal Responsibility","\u002Fprofiles\u002Ftarcisio\u002Fphoto.png","Q60392579",{"twitter":621},"tarcisiogdf",{"slug":623,"name":624,"party":557,"role":557,"state":557,"n_speeches":625,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":626,"photo_url":628,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":629,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":630},"luis-inacio-lula-da-silva","Luis Inacio Lula da Silva",10531,[586,574,627],"Benefits fraud & efficiency","\u002Fprofiles\u002Fluis-inacio-lula-da-silva\u002Fphoto.png","Q37181",{},{"slug":632,"name":633,"party":557,"role":557,"state":557,"n_speeches":634,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":635,"bio_short":557,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":637},"augusto-cury","Augusto Cury",8912,[606,636,586],"Agribusiness \u002F Environment",{},{"slug":639,"name":640,"party":557,"role":557,"state":595,"n_speeches":641,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":642,"photo_url":643,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":644,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":645},"kim-kataguiri","Kim Kataguiri",8748,[561,617,574],"\u002Fprofiles\u002Fkim-kataguiri\u002Fphoto.png","Q21715169",{"twitter":646},"@KimKataguiri",{"slug":648,"name":649,"party":557,"role":557,"state":650,"n_speeches":651,"consistency_score":6,"top_topics":652,"photo_url":654,"bio_short":557,"wikidata_id":655,"mandate_status":565,"social_links":656},"flavio-bolsonaro","Flavio Bolsonaro","RJ",8066,[586,574,653],"Anti-Fascism","\u002Fprofiles\u002Fflavio-bolsonaro\u002Fphoto.png","Q10283057",{"twitter":657},"@FlavioBolsonaro",null]